Baby deaths Scotland: Demands for high number of newborn deaths to be debated at Scottish Parliament

There have been calls for baby deaths to be debated at the Scottish Parliament

Ministers are facing calls for “proper scrutiny” into a rise in baby deaths in Scotland – with Liberal Democrats demanding a report into the issue be debated at Holyrood.

The Scottish Government commissioned Healthcare Improvement Scotland to carry out a review after there was a higher than expected number of deaths involving newborns in both March 2022 and September 2021.

Jenni Minto, the minister for public health and women’s health, insisted the Scottish Government had “accepted the findings of the report and recommendations” and was now “working on the next steps”. But Scottish Liberal Democrat leader Alex Cole-Hamilton insisted the Government should also schedule time for the issue to be debated in Holyrood.

A Healthcare Improvement Scotland review found there were 135 neonatal deaths – those which occur within 28 days of birth – in Scotland between April 2021 and March 31 2022. Picture: Dominic Lipinski/PA Wire

He spoke out after the Healthcare Improvement Scotland review found there were 135 neonatal deaths – those which occur within 28 days of birth – in Scotland between April 2021 and March 31 2022.

When compared to the previous four years, there were an estimated 30 additional deaths over the course of the year. However, the review did not find evidence of systemic failures of maternity or neonatal care or “unusual factors” that would explain the increase.

Ms Minto, in a letter to Mr Cole-Hamilton, accepted the increase in mortality was “concerning”. She said: “The report noted at the outset that there was no evidence of systemic failures in maternity or neonatal care, or any unusual factors or a cluster of any one factor to explain the increase in neonatal deaths in this period.

“Whilst this provides some reassurance, the increase in mortality remains concerning and the Scottish Government remains committed to improvement in maternity and neonatal safety across Scotland.”

But she said there were “no plans” for the issue to be debated at Holyrood with the minister instead saying MSPs would be informed via letter of the work the Government is doing.

However, Mr Cole-Hamilton said: “If there is time for Parliament to hold a series of debates on the Scottish Government’s ridiculous independence papers, there is time for proper scrutiny of important public health matters like this.”

The Liberal Democrat MSP stated: “There can be few more pressing priorities for a government than uncovering why the death rate among newborn babies has spiked. That’s why I wrote to the public health minister to press for these reports to be published after they were delayed last year.

“Alongside taking forward the recommendations from the healthcare improvement Scotland report, I would urge the Scottish Government to schedule time for Parliament to discuss this report.”

A Scottish Government spokesperson said: “We have accepted the findings and recommendations of Healthcare Improvement Scotland’s (HIS) report and are working on next steps with partners – including HIS, Public Health Scotland and the Scottish Perinatal Network.

“The HIS review found no evidence of systemic failures of maternity or neonatal care, unusual factors or a cluster of any one factor that would account for the significant increase in neonatal deaths in 2021/22.

“We recognise the tragedy of losing a baby and the impact Health Improvement Scotland’s report may have on grieving families and would encourage those who need additional support to get in touch with Sands or one of the other baby loss charities who provide bereavement support.”